I wish these fit because they are gorgeous! With warm socks on, these always felt about half a size too small to me on one foot, so I only wore them a handful of times, but they are comfortable and cloud-like. (My feet are two different sizes. The smaller foot fits and is incredibly comfortable, but the larger foot is just too small to be enjoyable.) They are warm. I have no idea how they got scuffed with such little wear. Maybe I couldn't feel my feet? Aside from the scuffs shown, they are like new. You will love them! I'm usually a 7.5, so they would probably be best for someone with size 6.5 or 7 feet or a 7.5 who wears thinner socks than I do. They live in a pet-friendly, smoke-free house.