Welcome to Tieks, the most comfortable and stylish ballet flat in all the land! I have been a loyal customer of this brand since 2012. Stylish and sophisticated, Tieks are the perfect complement to any outfit. This pair of Tortoiseshell Tieks have been well worn but well cared for and have many miles left in them. Please review the photos closely - you will see that the left shoe has scuffing and cracking to the patent leather - the most visible spot is on the top part of the shoe near the big toe (they appear as two fine white lines). Other areas are not visible unless you stretch out the shoe to visualize it. Of note, none of these markings stand out when wearing the shoe. I live in a smoke and pet free home, and I have only ever worn these shoes with the peds, a special sock made for flats, for good hygiene. May you wear them well!