Red Perez shine flats

Left flat:inside it just a small unnoticeable like crack, bottom of shoe it's kinda slightly chipped at the toe part. Other than that it's all good! right flat: top of toe part where the little like toe bow it's got like 2 scratches, back of shoe on the outside at the bottom has part of the heel scratched off but it's barely noticeable. size: 7 Made in : China Style name: Perez shine