Like NEW!! These were my favorite shoes. I wore them with everything. They were only slightly worn until my puppy decide to chew on the inside flap. However, I still wore them even after that… honestly with black socks, once they’re laced up, you can barely tell. I still marked them way down for this. Other than that, they look great. I finally bought a new pair but thought about keeping these to wear when running errands. They really aren’t bad at all. Questions? Leave a comment below! SOLD