This POTTERY BARN Season’s Greetings Christmas Tree Set of 4 Appetizer Dessert Plates has been used once and all EXCEPT one plate is in excellent condition. There are two tiny chips on the tips of the red star on one plate (see close up with chips noted with arrow). White marks on plates are reflections from my lights and are not flaws. Please zoom in to see details and message me with any questions you may have before ordering.