I had these flats for a few years now, but only worn them for a year straight as I showed every little dirt speck I was able to find. These shoes show no signs of peeling, odor, loose threading; just the insoles and soles have dirt from outside wear. Comes with box and dust bags. I’m sure if you take it somewhere they can clean the shoe to make it good as new. The box also shows signs of wear and tear. I’ll rate the shoe a 7.5/10!!!