I bought these shoes in 2019 (I believe) from Madewell. They are in pretty good condition. There are a couple teeny tiny random black specks on the white outer material that aren't really noticable (see pic 5). The sherpa on the inside is worn in and has some lint (see pic 6). There is a lighter mark on the right side of the left shoe (see pic 7). It is super small and pretty much unnoticable when worn. There is a light brown mark on the outside of the white part of the shoe (see pics 8 and 9). It isn't very noticable either. These come from a smoke-free home. We do have pets, so keep in mind there may be a few dog hairs. I did clean the shoes prior to listing, but pet hair gets everywhere lol. Size 9 in women, 7.5 in men.