Unused Clutch by Alexander McQueen with dustbag and marks

unused initially priced at $3990 Alexander McQueen quilted black and white clutch with gunmetal jeweled knuckles, had a hanging tag and authentication cards included, was already authenticated by Poshmark, 12"x7"x0.5", one knuckle slightly chipped, was never used by me but after authentication a buyer returned it with a few marks and scratches on leather, see pictures. It has been already authenticated by Poshmark, was purchased by me new and still never been used by me