Anthropologie Guilhermina Heart Mule Heels Size 40 The box says they are a size 41, but the shoe says these are a size 40 US 9. They fit like a size 9. I bought these from Anthropologie but sprained my ankle. 5 months later, still sprained. NWOB Plastic Upper Leather insole Rubber Sole Plastic Heel Slip-on style Heel Height = 2.5" Super fast shipping. Smoke-free home.