New, flawed. These sat in a closet for quite a while. The inside black lining is peeling off and coming out. They were quite dusty with what looked like cat hairs. If you find any others, which you shouldn't, I apologize. This will not affect the wear. Marc Fisher Melendya, black pointed toe patent leather Oxford heels with black and white herringbone and tie tops. No Box! Size 8 1/2 Heel measures approximately 4" 0640024