This is a new palette, but I did swatch a couple of the colors. Then, when I was cleaning up the palette to take pics, it looks like my alcohol wipe bumped up against the color "Sandbar" (see pic aboce.) It *looks* like the palette has had a rough life, when in honesty, it's lived a life of comfort in a drawer! I'm selling palette because I just can't master eyeshadow! What the heck?!