THEY ARE BRAND NEW. THE 2 CROC CHARMS HAVE NEVER BEEN USED ON ANY CROCS. ALSO. CROC CHARMS ARE ALREADY DISCOUNTED, IF I DROP TO $5.00, WOULD ONLY MAKE $.03, BEST DEAL, IF WONT A DISCOUNT 2 FOR $10.00 IF YOU PURCHASE 2 SETS OF CHARMS IN A BUNDLE, I WILL DO 2 SETS FOR $10