SO sad these didn’t fit because they’re BEAUTIFUL!!! and in PERFECT CONDITION- never been worn- i bought off of posh and am a true size 10- these were a smidge to snug for me- IMO would fit a size 9.5 perfectly! I’ve never worn APL sneakers so i’m not for sure if is this normal for the brand or this shoe specifically but i’d recommend if you’re a 9.5! white and navy/black