I purchased them on TOMS website when they just came out. See pictures for details. The shoe paddings are all clean. My baby wore them with socks. There are some light brown spots on the right shoe vamp of the Velcro pair and the Velcro part on the left one.(details on picture 5) There are some wear and tear on the bows of the Snow White pair.(details on picture 6) The silver Cinderella pair is in great conditions. The wedge of all three pairs are clean.