Lip liner and lip plumper bumdle

All 3 lip liners are the nyx line loud lip liners that genuinely are the best lip liners on the market in my case since they last so long however i got a diffrent shade that i like more than this one. The lip plumer is really pigmented and the colour it gives on the lips is the same as on the bottle. In my opinion it doesbt really plump the lips since i dont feel any tingling sensation but my lips do feel cold when wearing it.