New Loafers Size 8.5 Fits Like 9.5

Brand new NY and Company loafers with lovely bow detail. Size 8.5 but fits much larger, like a 9.5 in my opinion. For reference, I’m consistently a 9 and these are big enough that I can’t wear them. Note: these are listed as two listings, one with the listed size and one with the estimated actual size for Poshers searching for 9.5s.