Birdie's popular "Starling" flats in classic black velvet and quilted gold interior. These were very lightly worn and look new inside and outside. They are structurally sound, haven't been conformed to the shape of someone else's foot. There is one small worn spot in the velvet at the heel of the right shoe, only noticeable upon close inpection. Very light wear on the sole bottoms. See last 3 pics. Size 9