Accepting offers! NO TRADES!

Name: Accepting offers! NO TRADES!
Brand: Meet the Posher
SKU: 587af3f4ae6145d66508caae
Availability: OutOfStock

Meet the Posher

US$0

Size

Not for sale

Like and save for later

Hi! I'm Caitlin. I'm 23 years old and from New Hampshire. Some of my favorite brands are J. Crew, Madewell, Banana Republic, and Anthropologie. When I'm not shopping I like to go hiking, play with my cats, and annoy my fiancé. Thanks for stopping by! I accept reasonable offers and offer a bundle discount!

Category

Women

Other

Shipping/Discount

Ships to: United States
$7.97 Expedited (1-3 day) Shipping on all orders

acq127 and 94 others like this

153 Comments

normaagarcia Welcome to Poshmark 🌟

Jan 16Reply

minromano Thanks, I got compliment everyone. The fabric is so beautiful and glamorous

Jan 16Reply

vintagesunshine @minromano what?

Jan 16Reply

minromano @vintagesunshine I meant my Alice+Olivia dress, I saw u like it.

Jan 16Reply

patriciamildred @vintagesunshine hi Caitlin welcome to Poshmark it's lots of fun I also love vintage and have wonderful pieces if you have questions about anything at all I'd be glad to help

Jan 16Reply

especiallyforyo Thank you so much for all the shares✨have a wonderful day

Jan 17Reply

bonbon0512 Welcome to Poshmark!!!!

Jan 21Reply

bonbon0512 PS. I have tons of Banana republic and J. Crew

Jan 21Reply

joyamarino I just had to stop by and say Hi 🌸 and welcome you to Poshmark. I would be happy to help should you have any questions...use the @ sign before my closet name @joyamarino to tag me 🌸💖 Have a fabulous Tomorrow ☀️~ Joy

Jan 22Reply

martinigirl27 💐WELCOME TO POSHMARK💐 I'm happy to help if you have any questions getting started💐 Happy POSHing💐

Jan 24Reply

feministfox Hi!

Jan 31Reply

vintagejunque hi Caitlin! Welcome to Poshmark 💗

Feb 03Reply

mmw323 Welcome to Poshmark!

Feb 04Reply

vicgea @vintagesunshine Hi V. Welcome to Posh. Have fun. Happy Poshing😊🌹

Feb 05Reply

bestdealsusa Pretty 🌹

Feb 08Reply

pdxmangoslice Love your closet!

Mar 04Reply

vintagesunshine @ragtimemachine thank you! 😊

Mar 06Reply

jessregelson Lovely closet!!!

Mar 09Reply

drkitty5 Thank u beautiful for share my list 😘❤😸blessings

Mar 19Reply

dealsbyeddie Thanks for sharing , Caitlin !We accept reasonable. Offers.

Mar 24Reply

fivetenandahalf Thanks so much for following my closet, yours is great! Shared one of my faves

Mar 26Reply

callielives Thanks for poshing around in my closet 💃🏽😘❤️ I just price dropped every item by $7!!! The prices will go back up starting at 9PM EST

Apr 21Reply

lila6636 @vintagesunshine You have the most organized closet I've ever seen on Poshmark!!!! 😍😍😍

Apr 23Reply

vintagesunshine @lila6636 thank you! It took me a while to get it organized!

Apr 23Reply

lila6636 @vintagesunshine Well great job!

Apr 23Reply

kfortino69 Thank you for sharing my closet 😘

Apr 26Reply

acgerfin @vintagesunshine Thank you for the share😊

Apr 26Reply

therobins_nest I love your closet! You have a great variety and something for everyone 💕

May 12Reply

lgsteinke You, my Dear, have an awesome closet!

May 14Reply

rosieismypuppy 💝💝Thank you for visiting my closet. I'm Wendy, I would love an opportunity to serve YOU. Reasonable offers are welcomed, and I provide a bundle discount. Have a wonderful day and happy poshing.💝💝

May 15Reply

honeylosangeles Hey Caitlin🌼 In honor of Memorial Day I am offering same-day shipping and 15% off purchases of 3+ items. Happy Poshing!

May 28Reply

drunkonclothes Thanks for the share, so sweet!!💕💕🐘🐘

Jun 12Reply

ravenandrussell @vintagesunshine props to you for color coordinating you closet 🙌🏻!!

Jun 22Reply

splendidpoppy Beautiful closet!!! So well done. ..... So easy to share.....👍🏻👍🏻👗👗👗👍🏻👍🏻🌺🌺

Jun 24Reply

veraellenmillar I love the way your closet is organized!! How would you insert a new purple listing into your feed? I was trying to keep side by side items similar, then messed up and I don't know how to insert new items into the feed farther down. Does that make sense? Thank you in advance for your help.

Jun 25Reply

vintagesunshine @veraellenmillar when you share an item it brings it to the top of your closet, so share items in the order you want them to be in and always share in that order. It can get a bit difficult but I think it's worth it!

Jun 25Reply

veraellenmillar @vintagesunshine thank you! Again, your closet is lovely.

Jun 25Reply

datpiff99 Your photos are stunning and so clear!!!

Jun 29Reply

emilyrose18322 Hi girl thanks for the follow please note that I take great offers on bundles so never hesitate to ask me ☺️☺️

Jul 01Reply

ashleyandme01 Wow Caitlin your closet is sooo organized!! I love how it's like all white, then purple, then it turns all colorful 😊 they're all lovely! Just wanted to stop by and Happy Poshing! ❤️

Jul 03Reply

jkat_12 Colored coordinated closets are my favorite. So visually pleasing and easy to navigate. I do this in my own closet and hope to get there with my Posh closet as well. Job well done 💜👏🏽💜

Jul 07Reply

srugarik U have a perfectly organized closet... :-) I love it... nice collection :-)

Jul 11Reply

cair38 I love the way your closet is organized! Very nice selection.

Jul 12Reply

jmc83 @vintagesunshine Hi Caitlin, I have to agree with the persons comment before mine. I also wanted to apologize for just hitting The deny button. There were some things in The bundle that I did not want… Example the bathing suit top that I cannot get off. And other things that I could not put on. I wanted to talk to you about it and see if we could work something out.

Jul 13Reply

jmc83 Thank you very much for your time. If I do not get back to you right away is because I have to run errands real quick. Thank you for understanding.

Jul 13Reply

vintagesunshine @jmc83 it's not a problem at all! Is your current bundle what you'd be interesting in purchasing if we can reach an agreement on the price?

Jul 13Reply

vintagesunshine @jmc83 it's 6 pairs of shorts, 2 sweaters, and a romper? If that's right, I will make you an offer on the bundle!

Jul 13Reply

poshmark1111112 Your closet looks fantastic!

Jul 17Reply

megtuttle @vintagesunshine - Hi! I just wanted to compliment you on your closet. You coordinated the colors perfectly. I usually just browse closets very quickly but yours captivated my interest by the color groupings which made my viewing it very pleasurable !!! Well done darlin!!!! LOVE, LOVE LOVE your closet!!!! xo, meg

Jul 21Reply

celestialz I love your closet! I just ordered a similar backdrop and lighting as my pictures are currently terrible. I'm focusing on selling to recoup my costs, but think the investment will be worth it. I'll continue to drop in.

Jul 21Reply

samantha_sf_ca Hi Caitlin, I really like your closet. I went a little crazy on the sharing. Once I started, I couldn't stop. I'm not working right now, so I can't afford to buy anything.

Jul 23Reply

samantha_sf_ca There was one dress I really like. I am going to put in a real lowball offer. I don't know how long you've been trying to sell it or if you would consider such a low offer. No offense intended. Just hit decline. I'll return once I'm working and gave money. Again, I really like your closet. I had a great time looking through it. Have a fun weekend!

Jul 23Reply

vintagesunshine @sammmmmmmy thank you for the offer! I'm not offended at all. I'm going to counter with my lowest just so you know how much you'd need if you'd like to purchase in the future!

Jul 23Reply

samantha_sf_ca @vintagesunshine Thanks so much!!

Jul 23Reply

friendlyflyer Thanks for the great price ! I am a plus size but wanted to share some of your closet ..

Jul 24Reply

jessilynn143 Thank you babe for sharing my listing your a sweetheart form your westcoast friend.

Jul 25Reply

allaribalta Hi! So, I'm brand spanking new - TODAY! 1st listings, 1st comments. Gotta ask: HOW ARE U Color coordinating your listings? Wait! Is that a dumb question? Is it just a matter of listing like colors together? Or is it a trick! Very nicely done! Love the skorts too. Right up my alley! I'll get this thing figured out & share some cool skorts....

Jul 26Reply

vintagesunshine @allaribalta Welcome to Poshmark! I love skorts and wish my closet was just full of them! Every time you either share or edit your own listing, it brings it to the top of your closet. Try sharing or editing an item, then leave your closet and go back and it should be on the top. I color coordinated it a few months ago and when I add new items, I just share that item between two other items of the same color. Hope that helps!

Jul 26Reply

allaribalta @vintagesunshine Soooooooo smart! Thanks for telling me. So glad to know how u did that! I love the way yours looks! I'm a little bit of a perfectionist. But should really just force myself to start listing...instead of marathon browsing...& trying to follow advice, share the love. Lotta work, this PM. Wish I could snap my fingers & be out of the awkward newbie stage! Hope I remember how to reconnect so I can share my skorts! So many! It's probably not even healthy! Lol!

Jul 26Reply

amasquared @allaribalta @vintagesunshine I was once just a browser too.... It is a lot of work, but JUMP OVER THE FENCE & TRY IT!!! I am having a blast, and seeing vintage sunshine's closet literally made me inspired lol!!! I'm having so much fun with it that I'm helping a few friends actually set it up & do it. Huge time investment, yes, but awesome. No more guilt for staying in when it's too hot to "play" outside... you can make some $! And new friends!!

Aug 01Reply

babyblusam I would so love to make a bundle but I've already spent too much this paycheck! Right now I can only do trades. :(

Aug 12Reply

robinana Thanks for the share! I appreciate it! 😊

Aug 17Reply

jesuischic @vintagesunshine sorry i jumped the gun sending an offer! 🙈 feel free to shoot me an offer whenever you are ready too!

Aug 21Reply

random_sequence @vintagesunshine What a gorgeous closet! Love your style! 👍

Sep 29Reply

okiegirlnm Well Caitlin, you have a very organized closet. I live that you group alike color together when possible. And you have so many lovely items in your closet. I could possibly shop in your closet alone and be able to acquire whatever outfit I may need for pleasure or a special event. You have a very wide range of sizes. And I know that I will be making a bundle offer sooner Then later. I’m 65 yrs old but chose to dress as I have always dressed. Within reason..

Oct 01Reply

okiegirlnm In closing I wish you much success. And just a last note my granddaughter & you have the same name just spelt differently. Her’s is spelt Katelyn.

Oct 01Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm hi, I had to update the sale sign as not for sale so you weren't charged for it! I'll take a look at the bundle and let you know my lowest offer!

Oct 01Reply

okiegirlnm @vintagesunshine I a bit confused. I purchased 7 items at your counter offer of $135.00.. Mow is that what I am getting or is there a problem.?

Oct 01Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm you purchased 8 for $135 and you will be getting all of that, I will ship it out tomorrow! Originally you had 9 items in a bundle, one of which was my bundle sale sign, and that was adding $3 extra, so I marked the sign not for sale. This brought your bundle down to 8 items and I made an offer which you accepted.

Oct 01Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm I never accepted your original offer, please see your above comments where you acknowledge that I made an offer of $135 and you accepted. I was running a limited time 30% off bundle sale and gave you an extra discount on top of that because you were making such a large purchase. I have already shipped your package out and I hope you love everything!

Oct 03Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm also, when you accepted my offer it was in the afternoon. I'm sorry you're confused, but you accepted my counter offer of $135 and I shipped the items out this morning. You can see above where you acknowledge that you purchased at the price of $135

Oct 03Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm I had the 30% discount selected, and then I made you an offer that was lower than that, so you received more than a 30% discount. I'm not sure what you think I did wrong but there's no way I could have made you purchase at $135.

Oct 03Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm This is exactly what happened on my end: I received your offer for $125 and I noticed you had bundled my sale sign. I then marked the sign not for sale and left a comment (seen above) to let you know what happened and then I countered with my lowest offer of $135. You accepted the offer 4:39 PM EST (this is when the email with the shipping label was sent to me).

Oct 03Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm After you accepted, you saw my comment and responded saying that you purchased for $135 and asking if there was a problem. I responded explaining what I did with the sale sign so you wouldn't be charged for it. I then packaged up your order and dropped it off to the 24 hour post office in my area. When I woke up, you had commenting saying there was an issue and I overcharged you.

Oct 03Reply

vintagesunshine @okiegirlnm I'm sorry that you feel that I did something wrong, but I made you an offer of $135 and you accepted, and then I shipped it out ASAP so you would receive it quickly. I'm not sure what the problem is.

Oct 03Reply

hmsimon1 Good morning Caitlin. Thank you for choosing to follow my creations 🌹

Oct 08Reply

savle @vintagesunshine how will I be charged shipping if I purchase both items? Being as they will be shipped together

Oct 16Reply

vintagesunshine @savle I'm sorry, but the 2 items cannot be shipped together as I've already shipped the dress. I was on my way to the post office when you made an offer on the romper. If you had bundled before purchasing, you would've received a bundle discount and only been charged one shipping fee.

Oct 16Reply

savle @vintagesunshine ok, thank you.

Oct 16Reply

monalisavi New at the "styling thing". Hard for me since I have a hard time trying to "style" myself! No pressure on anything but do let me know if you have questions. I shared a post about going on vacation. I am one that will "hold" for certain people if needed😉. Thanks for allowing me to style you✨

Nov 15Reply

thehoneyposh Great Closet!! 😍💕

Jan 14Reply

tastykake28 Thanks for sharing

Jan 18Reply

jacaranda1831 Thanks for $haring.

Feb 01Reply

jenandchase Nice closet! Thanks for sharing... I love how you have your closet organized by color!

Mar 21Reply

natxander2009 Hey !! I'm going to have to decline the offer on dress just measured my self and it won't fit sorry😫

Mar 25Reply

isisportillo Hi gorgeous thank you for looking at my closet and sharing the love. If you like anything please let me know. I want to clean my closet so I will consider your offer.

Mar 29Reply

pickyourbling Don’t trade with melisa1245

May 11Reply

vintagesunshine @dgoll11307 I don’t trade. I’m not sure why you’re warning me?

May 11Reply

pickyourbling @vintagesunshine @samoha she stole a Michael kors purse, wallet, and backpack from my wife in a trade she was supposed to send my wife a pink sequin coach bag but sent 3 crappy bags instead. Please pass it on

May 11Reply

thrift4smiles Stylish closet! Let me know if you’re interested in anything! I am flexible with prices.

May 11Reply

tgolder Thank you for sharing my posting

May 17Reply

lexiga Hi Caitlin! Thank you for liking my handmade jewelry. Please let me know if you have any questions ☺

Jun 08Reply

hmmmocha Hello ❤! Great job on your closet. Wishing you much success ❤

Jun 14Reply

new_vintage_nyc We have the agreed price and shipping discount and there’s the next 24 hours of nothin then time runs out. they don’t make me an official offer or just buy it right there for that price so i am trying to build a bridge over that gap from where it’s at a good price you’re not paying full price for shipping but you don’t want it anymore I mean because it happens all like 10 times a day . Am I am missing something or is that normal???

Jun 14Reply

minz29 Great closet!

Jun 20Reply

bdelpont Thanks for following me! Check out my closet anytime! Happy Monday!

Jul 02Reply

cherylamme Great closet! You wear a lot of black 🙃

Jul 20Reply

adeav Hey love ! You might enjoy some of my items which include brands like American Eagle, Under Armour, Adidas, Altar’d State, H&M, Nike, Polo, LOFT, VS Pink, Abercrombie and Fitch, Hollister, Urban Outfitters, Loft, Simply Southern, Vera Bradley, Banana Republic, and More !!! Always open to offers and bundles are guaranteed discounts :)))

Jul 31Reply

nickrainone3 Check out some of my bags, if you like any let me know

Aug 16Reply

yotacion Thank you for sharing my listing!

Aug 21Reply

cutecloset17 Hi Caitlin, I purchased green shirts from you. The tracking shows that the shorts are at a post office in New Hampshire. Can you take a look please? Thanks, Cindy

Aug 22Reply

vintagesunshine @cutecloset17 unfortunately there was a mix up at the post office and they scanned all my packages as delivered instead of shipped. The package should still be on its way to you and will hopefully be scanned with updated shipping.

Aug 22Reply

groomsland Hi, CONGRATS on hosting the Men's Style Party! If possible, please come check out my boutique, where I offer a range of unique style accessories for men. I hope that if you like my items, you would choose one as a host pick for the party. Thank you!!!

Aug 24Reply

susan_messmer Hi Caitlyn...I just got the brown velvet off the shoulder dress...OMG...it is absolutely PERFECT!! Thank u so much! Susan

Oct 11Reply

vintagesunshine @susan_messmer I’m so glad you love it! I was holding on to it for a while, but it was too small for me so I’m happy it went to somebody who will give it the love it deserves!

Oct 11Reply

susan_messmer The most amazing thing is I almost NEVER find what I envision and this dress is exactly what I envisioned before I even saw it on Poshmark...thank you again, so much!

Oct 11Reply

nlsc13 Your color coordinated closet looks great!!

Dec 10Reply

lovefashionyay Hi 👋 WELCOME! I’m Jacquelyn posh ambassador! L❤️VE ur closet!😍! Would L💕VE T💗 have u ❤️N my tag list & join my x-mas $ale/Share event! Exclusive for PFF’s 💜NLY & 50 spots avail! It’s posted up in my closet! I shared ur adorably cute closet! ! Ty! Happy 😃 poshing! 🎅 🛷 🦌 🎄 ⛄️ ❄️ X-MAS $ALE/SHARE EVENT!! December 19-21st! Adding more X-Mas items soon!!! ❄️ Happy Holidays!! 🧥🧤🧣👢☕️ 🎁 💍

Dec 12Reply

gigi11155 Hi I’m Debbie! Nice to meet you and if you get a chance please stop by and see if there’s something you just can’t live without and I would love to be HP!!❤️👍😊

Dec 14Reply

ajwitt76 Your closet is a rainbow of fun🤗 love the puppy pic🐾

Dec 14Reply

roguebanana Gorgeous closet!! I just couldn’t stop sharing!! 💕☺️

Dec 14Reply

dicsally Hello Just purchased rainbow shirt and I need for a party on Saturday. I’m hoping you can ship it out today or I can pay for expedited shipping let me know thanks so much

Jan 16Reply

vintagesunshine @dicsally I’m packaging it up right now actually!

Jan 16Reply

vintagesunshine @dicsally so I will be dropping it off at the post office today ☺️

Jan 16Reply

dicsally Thank you so much!

Jan 16Reply

mightyfinds You're the REAL MVP! Thanks for sharing! 😊🤙🏼🙌🏽

Jan 19Reply

carriezhu I apologize. Could you cancel my order? I never own a Loft. So I just realized the balzer I purchased from you is too small for me. Sorry for the inconvenience.

Jan 19Reply

carriezhu Sorry, just ignore the above. I want keep it for my sister. Thanks.

Jan 19Reply

fedzosdad I've been hardly able to take my new bra off! :)) Talk about a 'home run/Grand Slam'!!! I look so 4ward 2 shopping more with you. ted

Mar 24Reply

jzrose Hi Caitlin. I declined the offer on the Anthropolgie dress because I hadn’t read the measurements before you sent the offer. The sizing is too small for me. Thank you though! :)

Apr 13Reply

chante_allday Thank you for following me! I want to also invite you to follow my Instagram I want to grow that account so its just as successful as this one can’t do so without your support ! I’ll return the favor @chante_all day

Jul 28Reply

kozy_kloset Thanks for following my Closet & Sharing ! 😘💜🛍

Aug 10Reply

wondergiz Thanks for following my closet, Blessings from Puerto Rico, Gisela 🙏🍀🤩🍀🙏

Aug 12Reply

lellowandpink Thanks for the follow! Have a great day and happy selling! 🤙

Sep 09Reply

bobbett328 Hello🙋‍♀️Thank you so much for stopping by and following my closet 🌺🥰 Happy Poshing 🛍🛍

Sep 18Reply

calamity_dawn Thank you for sharing my necklace - I just sold it!!!! You are MAGIC!

Oct 01Reply

slink475 Really nice closet! ❤️

Oct 14Reply

_bryanna_13 Thanks for the follow! Check out my closet and like/bundle any items you’re interested in. All bundles of 3 or more items get an automatic 20% discount and I try to offer another discount on top of that for any size bundle you create. I’m open to offers. I’m just trying to clear out my closet while I’m home! Have a great day!

Dec 22Reply

gabcasanas Thanks for sharing! Cute closet 💕

Jan 11Reply

ramosadam92 Awe a little puppy and nice to meet you ma'am. Thank you ma'am for letting me look in your closet.

Jan 14Reply

maedecember Thanks for the follow @vintagesunshine ! I look forward to Poshing with you!

Feb 07Reply

yoked1990 Thanks for the follow beautiful 😌

Feb 07Reply

jr60st Hi

Feb 19Reply

thistleandarrow Hi Caitlin! Thank you so much for the share. It’s greatly appreciated! Happy Poshing! 🥰

Mar 11Reply

lamorfashions Hey!😊 Thanks so much for the follow! Just wanted to let you know we are currently running a sale: 3 for $25!! Bundle any three items with 🌼 symbol and an offer for $25 will be sent to you... OR... you can send an offer for $25 and it will be accepted. Free shipping on bundles $49 or more! Sale ends Monday, March 30, 2020 & 11:59 pm est. Let me know if you have any questions. Happy poshing!😊

Mar 27Reply

sandaleigh I accepted your bundle offer now I see the shorts price was lowered ?

May 09Reply

vintagesunshine @sandaleigh I’m sorry? I don’t know what you mean. I sent you an offer for buy one get one free and you accepted and I shipped the bundle out yesterday.

May 09Reply

sandaleigh Sorry believe it or not another person had the same shorts in their closet😀I didn’t realize I liked another pair.

May 09Reply

vintagesunshine @sandaleigh no problem!

May 09Reply

mresse hi! welcome. I have some super gorgeous items for sale at my closet and I'd love for you to take a look. Everything is completely price negotiable. HURRY AS I'M CLOSING IN AUGUST!

Jul 31Reply

greenbaypackers Hi Caitlin😀! Thanks for the follow. Am following you now too. Love💕your fur baby!!! Super cute!!!! Excited to check out your closet. FYI if ever interested in anything in mine, I'm always open to offers & take 20% off bundles of 2+ items. Hope you have a great day💁🏼, stay healthy & safe in all this craziness & Keep Poshing🛍!!!

Sep 16Reply

lisacloset4u Hello fellow Posher; just wanted to stop by say hello, hope you’re having fun shopping & selling, stop by my closet & if you see something you like! like it! for a fabulous discount always clean sanitize shipping Stay positive, test negativ

Oct 26Reply

sprinklesbaker Hey thanks for following me I’m Emily if you like anything from my closet create a bundle for a great deal! Happy Holidays😊

Nov 22Reply

kotahs_kloset Adorable closet! Have a wonderful day! 🥰

Dec 11Reply

jasonallen476 Such a cute puppy! Is that a pug?

Jan 31Reply

crafteelinda490 Thanks for following my closet. I have shared some of yours.. Stay safe and God bless.

Feb 25Reply

_lo97 Hi, thanks for the follow!Check out my shop, you might just find something you love🤍

Mar 27Reply

martinbd6029 I hope that you will check out my closet

Apr 10Reply

skylight31 Hello my posh friends, 50% off this Saturday 5/15. checkout and place items inside the cart. To receive the discount on Saturday for purchase. Hurry items are moving.

May 12Reply

littlepeachxo hi ! ^^ i have a variety of listings & all earnings from my closet go to a child abuse survivor to help them heal. -peach ♡.

Nov 20Reply

beautifynails @vintagesunshine Hey there! Your closet is amazing. I would love to share yours away. Welcome to my closet at anytime. Thanks.

May 21Reply

cutehosiery @vintagesunshine Hey,there. I think you did a good job. Your closet is so exciting. Hope your business is doing better and better. Share your listings. Good luck.

Mar 22Reply

thriftwgrace INSANE $$$ DEALS TODAY Hi there! I wanted to share that we're updating our closet so we can feature more Fall/Winter merchandise. Therefore, we are entertaining ALL offers (up to 35% off in some cases) and remember that we post new items every weekend. Check us out and take advantage of this awesome opportunity. Happy Poshing, Grace

Nov 12Reply