This website requires JavaScript.
archetypo
archetypo
Updated Dec 23
archetypo
archetypo
Updated Dec 23

The Shoe Sizing Dilemma: how accurate are size charts anyway?

All the brands

C$5

Size
Like and save for later
Add To Bundle
This, my friends, is a problem I am far too familiar with, having spent megabucks on shoes online, only to experience the heartbreak of Ugly Stepsister Syndrome. All over Poshmark, I see people using the phrase, 'According to Poshmark's sizing chart, these should fit a 9.5 since they're marked 39.5', and I cringe, knowing that someone will fall in love, buy the shoes, then experience that same heartbreak. Well I'm here to tell you, having purchased shoes made in many corners of the globe, that THERE IS NO ONE STANDARD SIZING CHART! And also, even if you're generalizing, a size 39.5 is ALMOST ALWAYS equivalent to a size 8.5 - not 9.5. Shoe sizing is complicated. If you want your customers to be happy with the big ticket designer shoes they just bought, you need to be aware of a couple of things. 1. Every shoe manufacturer has their own sizing chart, and even within a single country, sizing can vary from one designer to the next. 2. If you're not familiar with a particular designer's sizing, then measurements are the only way to go. In my experience, high-end designer shoes tend to fit 1/2 to a full size smaller than mass market manufactured shoes, so comparing Manolo Blahnik sizing to Jessica Simpson isn't going to work. Your safest bet is to google each specific designer's sizing chart - yes, they all have them, and they're all different. Or measure the actual footbed length and width if you're not sure. Thank you for coming to my TED talk. 😎
Shipping/Discount
  • Seller Discount: 15% off 2+ Bundle

  • C$12.49 Expedited (1-7 day) Shipping on all orders

Posh Protect: Buyer Protection Policy

Get your order as described or receive your money back. Learn More.

22 Comments
archetypo
archetypo here's an interesting article on the history of shoe sizing - did you know that in England, sizes were originally based on the length of a barleycorn? https://threadcurve.com/shoe-size-conversion-charts/
Jan 19Reply
shoptiludrop64
shoptiludrop64 So true, I have also fallen victim to the Ugly Stepsister Syndrome too many times…so frustrating. I now ask for measurements of the insoles.
Jan 23Reply
archetypo
archetypo @shoptiludrop64 I know right? I'm always shocked at how many sellers, not just on Poshmark either, list things in US sizing that is entirely wrong - no, size 40 doesn't equal size 10! They're just setting themselves up for dissatisfied customers that way.
Jan 23Reply
shoptiludrop64
shoptiludrop64 @archetypo If you’ve bought the brand before you’re ok but with all the european sizes it’s a challenge. Lesson learned for me!
Jan 23Reply
archetypo
archetypo @shoptiludrop64 Exactly! I'd have to say that the 'official ' Poshmark sizing conversion chart for shoes is accurate less than 10% of the time.
Jan 23Reply
christstyle
christstyle Hi Anna very interesting write up I learn a few things thanks to you I am not even aware of Poshmark shoe size chart as with other stuff like how to take advantage of closet clear out or others they say drop your price by 10% minimum and then they will foot the bill for $0.99 or $6.99 shipping But why don’t I see a $0.99 shipping 🀣 or how I know if it was fulfilled so on and so forth thanks for listening to my questions take care Christine
Feb 21Reply
archetypo
archetypo @bzie I know, I find that very confusing myself. Basically, the catch is, if you drop your price 10% & the item DOESN'T sell, you have to keep dropping the price an additional 10% each time they run the promo in order to have the shipping bonus applied. It's insidious, and I guess eventually your stuff does sell - but I'm not a huge fan of being pressured to generate cashflow either. 😎
Feb 21Reply
christstyle
christstyle @archetypo I agree with you 100% it feels like they are nickel and dime you since that’s what you are left with after posh fee and the price dropπŸ₯Ί
Feb 21Reply
archetypo
archetypo @bzie I think it's OK to just ignore the promotions, don't let them pressure you! The right buyer will come along eventually.
Feb 21Reply
cdschreiber64
cdschreiber64 I got into this with another posher who sold me boots without mentioning that they were narrow - maybe he didn't realize, but I think he must have, because he's in the clothing industry. Anyway... I ended up blocking him, because he was rude and a bit aggressive, and, yes, shoe sizing is a complex issue.
Mar 11Reply
archetypo
archetypo @cdschreiber64 indeed! I'm always surprised when I see shoe listings described in a way that I know will lead to disappointment. I'm not sure if it's like vanity sizing with clothing or what exactly.
Mar 11Reply
cdschreiber64
cdschreiber64 @archetypo they were men's shoes. I wear a ladies' 13, so typically a men's 11, but they were quite small and oddly narrow - really my own fault for not asking measurements.
Mar 11Reply
ashleykipping
ashleykipping Ok so these are not for sale… right?
Jul 22Reply
archetypo
archetypo @ashleykipping nope, never selling this pair 😎
Jul 22Reply
ilys_apparel
ilys_apparel Hi Anna, I’m IN LOVE with all your shoes but my size 11 feet are oh so rarely a 41πŸ˜‰ Please, please tag me whenever your online endeavours prove (much) too large for your delicate wee 9.5-ish tootsies. It would be my pleasure to liberate any such gargantuan atrocities from your clutches. 😍
Sep 05Reply
archetypo
archetypo @ilys_apparel Good to know, it's more often than not people with smaller feet who benefit from my addiction, but I definitely do end up with larger pairs occasionally 😎
Sep 05Reply
archetypo
archetypo @ilys_apparel Also, roflmao at 'delicate wee tootsies' 🀣🀣🀣 There are no gargantuan atrocities, only Queen-sized glamour πŸ˜‚
Sep 05Reply
ilys_apparel
ilys_apparel @archetypo πŸ˜‚πŸ€£πŸ˜… I felt compelled to respond in kind to your creative post writing! πŸ˜‚πŸ€£πŸ˜… Also, thank you!
Sep 08Reply
reccawear
reccawear Great talk ! We should passing this around. , so more people can read it ? I have lots of followers I’ll post it & share. . I can also get more people on board ??
Nov 29Reply
reccawear
reccawear This is genius !!
Nov 29Reply
archetypo
archetypo @reccawear thanks, I hope it's helpful in some small way 😎
Nov 29Reply

Find Similar Listings

About the seller

archetypo

@archetypo

Last Active: 24 hours ago

Toronto, ON
View Closet

923

Listings

500+

Sold Listings

1 day

Avg. Ship time

100+

Love Notes

About the seller

archetypo

@archetypo

Last Active: 24 hours ago

Toronto, ON
View Closet

923

Listings

500+

Sold Listings

1 day

Avg. Ship time

100+

Love Notes